Some links earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. A commission never decides a pick. How we pick.

The short answer: a good wine gift suits the person and the occasion, and a high score from an independent critic takes the guesswork out of the bottle itself. Every wine below scored 90–100 points from Wine Enthusiast, and each was in stock at the retailer shown when its buy link was last checked. They run from about $23 to a once-in-a-lifetime splurge.

How to choose a wine gift

The Wine Society's Catherine Housden suggests setting a budget first, then thinking about the person before you browse. A favourite cuisine is a good guide: match the wine's flavour and weight to the food they love. A bottle from a region they have visited, or want to, makes a more personal present.1

For sparkling wine, she splits the choice in two: a richer style such as Champagne, Cava or Crémant, or a crisper, fruitier one such as Prosecco or Moscato d'Asti.1 Our Champagne vs Prosecco vs Cava guide explains how they differ.

John Wilson, wine columnist at The Irish Times, sizes the bottle to the gathering: inexpensive but not cheap for a big party, something better for an intimate dinner. He suggests asking a local wine shop for advice and a story to go with the bottle, and says lesser-known names can beat the classics, though Champagne is always welcome.2

Bringing wine to a host

A host does not have to open the bottle you bring. Wilson says it is a thank-you gift, and that opening it can suggest the host's own wines are not good enough; he opens a guest's bottle when the guest wants to share it, or when the house runs dry.2 Martha Stewart, quoted by Tasting Table, says a host is not obligated to open it unless it was brought for a dish being cooked.3

If you are the host this season, our Thanksgiving wine guide covers what to pour with turkey and the sides.

Under $30

Douloufakis Vidiano 2025 (Crete, Greece): a white that Wine Enthusiast's Emily Saladino scored 94 points in November 2026. Wine.com listed it at $22.99.4

Santa Julia El Zorrito Natural Skin Ferment Chardonnay 2025 (Mendoza, Argentina): an orange wine, 90 points from Jesica Vargas, $22.99 at Wine.com. A good pick for someone curious about orange wine.5

$50 to $100

Meerlust Rubicon 2021 (Stellenbosch, South Africa): a Bordeaux-style red blend, 95 points from Jesica Vargas, $55.99 at Wine.com.6

Roederer Estate L'Ermitage Brut 2019 (Anderson Valley, California): a Chardonnay–Pinot Noir sparkling wine that Tonya Pitts scored a perfect 100. Wine.com listed it at $82.99, which makes it the best-scored bottle here under $100.7

$200 to $250

Catena Zapata Adrianna Vineyard River Malbec 2022 (Mendoza, Argentina): 97 points from Jesica Vargas, $206.99 at Wine.com.8

Pago de los Capellanes Parcela El Picón 2019 (Ribera del Duero, Spain): 99 points from Mike DeSimone, $248 at Merchant of Wine.9

The splurge

Poggio di Sotto Riserva Brunello di Montalcino 2019 (Tuscany, Italy): 99 points from Danielle Callegari, $499.99 at Wine.com.10

Château Lafite Rothschild 2020 (Pauillac, Bordeaux): 100 points from Roger Voss, $749.99 at Wine.com.11

In the UK and Australia

Askaneli Gocha's Collection Muza Qvevri White 2019 (Georgia): 91 points from Emily Saladino, in stock at Hedonism Wines in the UK. Read more about Georgian wine before you give it.12

Prager Ried Achleiten Smaragd Riesling 2021 (Wachau, Austria): 98 points from Aleks Zecevic, A$142.29 at World Wine in Australia.13

Prices are as listed on the day each link was checked and can change. Pair a bottle with a cheese from our wine and cheese guide, or get the free Best Bottles checklist for each region's top-rated wine this month.

Bottles worth finding

Crete, Greece

Douloufakis 2025 Vidiano

94points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 94 points (Emily Saladino, issue of November 1, 2026, 2025 vintage). Read the full review

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.
Mendoza, Argentina

Santa Julia 2025 El Zorrito Natural Skin Ferment Chardonnay

90points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 90 points (Jesica Vargas, issue of July 1, 2026, 2025 vintage). Read the full review
How it's made
Santa Julia says it uses natural yeasts, adds no sulfites and doesn't filter this wine. Source

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.
Stellenbosch, South Africa

Meerlust 2021 Rubicon Bordeaux-Style Red Blend

95points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 95 points (Jesica Vargas, issue of November 1, 2026, 2021 vintage). Read the full review

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.
Anderson Valley, Mendocino County, California, United States

Roederer Estate 2019 L'Ermitage Brut Chardonnay-Pinot Noir

100points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 100 points (Tonya Pitts, issue of September 1, 2025, 2019 vintage). Read the full review

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.
Mendoza, Argentina

Catena Zapata 2022 Adrianna Vineyard River Malbec

97points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 97 points (Jesica Vargas, issue of July 1, 2025, 2022 vintage). Read the full review

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.
Ribera del Duero, Northern Spain, Spain

Pago de los Capellanes 2019 Parcela El Picón

99points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 99 points (Mike DeSimone, issue of October 1, 2024, 2019 vintage). Read the full review

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.
Brunello di Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy

Poggio di Sotto 2019 Riserva Brunello di Montalcino

99points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 99 points (Danielle Callegari, issue of December 31, 2025, 2019 vintage). Read the full review

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.
Pauillac, Bordeaux, France

Château Lafite Rothschild 2020 Pauillac

100points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 100 points (Roger Voss, issue of April 1, 2023, 2020 vintage). Read the full review

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.
Georgia (the country)

Askaneli 2019 Gocha's Collection Muza Qvevri White

91points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 91 points (Emily Saladino, issue of October 1, 2023, 2019 vintage). Read the full review

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.
Wachau, Austria

Prager 2021 Ried Achleiten Smaragd Riesling

98points
Evidence
Wine Enthusiast, 98 points (Aleks Zecevic, issue of May 1, 2023, 2021 vintage). Read the full review

We haven't tasted this wine. The pick rests on the independent review cited here.

Where to buy

Alcohol sales and shipping rules vary by country and state. The retailer confirms whether it can sell and ship to you.

Questions people ask

What is a good wine to give as a gift?

One the recipient will enjoy, at a price that suits the occasion. The Wine Society suggests setting a budget, then thinking about their interests: a favourite cuisine, or a region they love or want to visit. The bottles on this page all scored 90 points or more from Wine Enthusiast.

Does a host have to open the wine I bring?

No. The Irish Times wine columnist John Wilson says a bottle is a thank-you gift for the host, and Martha Stewart, quoted by Tasting Table, says a host is not obligated to open it unless it was brought for a dish being served.

How much should I spend on a wine gift?

There is no rule. John Wilson suggests something inexpensive but not cheap for a big party, and something better for an intimate dinner. This page starts at about $23.

Sources

  1. Catherine Housden, "Six tips on buying wine as a gift", The Wine Society (2024)
  2. John Wilson, "I am holding a dinner party. Should I open the wines my guests bring along as gifts?", The Irish Times (2024)
  3. Karen Hart, "What Martha Stewart Says To Do When A Dinner Guest Brings Wine", Tasting Table (2022)
  4. Emily Saladino, "Douloufakis 2025 Vidiano (Crete)", Wine Enthusiast (2026)
  5. Jesica Vargas, "Santa Julia 2025 El Zorrito Natural Skin Ferment Chardonnay (Mendoza)", Wine Enthusiast (2026)
  6. Jesica Vargas, "Meerlust 2021 Rubicon Bordeaux-Style Red Blend (Stellenbosch)", Wine Enthusiast (2026)
  7. Tonya Pitts, "Roederer Estate 2019 L'Ermitage Brut (Anderson Valley)", Wine Enthusiast (2025)
  8. Jesica Vargas, "Catena Zapata 2022 Adrianna Vineyard River Malbec (Mendoza)", Wine Enthusiast (2025)
  9. Mike DeSimone, "Pago de los Capellanes 2019 Parcela El Picón (Ribera del Duero)", Wine Enthusiast (2024)
  10. Danielle Callegari, "Poggio di Sotto 2019 Riserva (Brunello di Montalcino)", Wine Enthusiast (2025)
  11. Roger Voss, "Château Lafite Rothschild 2020 Pauillac", Wine Enthusiast (2023)
  12. Emily Saladino, "Askaneli 2019 Gocha's Collection Muza Qvevri White (Georgia)", Wine Enthusiast (2023)
  13. Aleks Zecevic, "Prager 2021 Ried Achleiten Smaragd Riesling (Wachau)", Wine Enthusiast (2023)