The short answer: Champagne comes from a protected area of France and gets its bubbles from a second fermentation in the bottle, mainly from Pinot Noir, Chardonnay and Meunier.1,6,13 Prosecco comes from northeast Italy, is based on Glera and is usually made sparkling in large tanks.2,9 Cava is Spanish and uses the same in-bottle method as Champagne, with grapes such as Macabeo, Xarel·lo and Parellada.8,14

Where each one comes from

Champagne became a protected appellation (AOC) in 1936. Only sparkling wine from the defined Champagne area, made by the Champagne process, can use the name, and the Comité Champagne says the name is protected in more than 130 countries.1

Prosecco DOC grapes must come from northeast Italy's Veneto and Friuli-Venezia Giulia regions. The zone spans nine provinces: Treviso, Venice, Vicenza, Padua, Belluno, Gorizia, Pordenone, Trieste and Udine.2,3

Conegliano Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore is a smaller, hilly zone about 50 km from Venice covering 15 communes. It was first recognized in 1969 and became a DOCG, Italy's top quality tier, in 2009.4

Cava's roots are in Spain's Penedès, especially the town of Sant Sadurní d'Anoia. For historical reasons it can also be made elsewhere. The DO has four zones, Comtats de Barcelona, Ebro Valley, Viñedos de Almendralejo and Requena, with sub-zones approved in 2020.5

How each is made

Champagne gets its bubbles in the bottle. A mix of still wine, sugar and yeast (the liqueur de tirage) is added at bottling, and the yeast turns the sugar into alcohol and carbon dioxide. The wine must stay in the bottle where this second fermentation happened.6

Champagne must age on its lees (spent yeast) for at least 15 months, and vintage Champagne for at least three years. The Comité says non-vintage wines usually age two to three years in practice, and vintage wines four to ten.7

Cava uses the same traditional method. After at least nine months on the lees, bottles are turned until the sediment collects in the neck, by hand or by machine. The neck is frozen so the plug of sediment can be removed, then the bottle is topped up with the dosage.8

Prosecco usually gets its bubbles in large sealed tanks called autoclaves, a technique the consortium calls the Martinotti method and Wine Folly calls the tank method. This second fermentation lasts at least 30 days for Spumante and Frizzante, and at least 60 days for Prosecco Rosé.9,10

Prosecco DOC comes in fully sparkling (Spumante), lightly sparkling (Frizzante) and still (Tranquillo) versions. One exception to the tank rule is Prosecco Superiore "sui lieviti," a traditional cloudy style fermented in the bottle, with no added sugar.9,11,12

Wine Folly links the method to the bubbles: the high pressure of the traditional method gives Champagne fine, persistent bubbles, while tank-method Prosecco has lighter, frothier bubbles that fade faster.10

The grapes

Champagne is mostly Pinot Noir (38% of vineyard area), Chardonnay (31%) and Meunier (31%). Five other authorized grapes, including Arbane, Petit Meslier, Pinot Blanc and Pinot Gris, cover about 0.3%.13

Prosecco is based on Glera. Other grapes, including Chardonnay, Pinot Bianco, Pinot Grigio and Pinot Nero, may make up no more than 15% in total.2

Prosecco Rosé blends Glera with 10–15% Pinot Nero made as a red wine. It is made only as Spumante, and only in the drier styles from Brut Nature to Extra Dry.9,11

Cava's classic blend is Macabeo, Xarel·lo and Parellada. Chardonnay has been allowed since 1986, and red grapes such as Garnacha, Trepat, Pinot Noir and Monastrell are used for rosé Cava.14

Age categories on the label

Cava's categories are set by time in bottle: Cava de Guarda at least 9 months, Reserva at least 18 months (raised in 2020), Gran Reserva at least 30 months, and Cava de Paraje Calificado at least 36 months.8,15,16,17

Reserva, Gran Reserva and Paraje Calificado belong to Cava de Guarda Superior, which requires organically grown grapes from specific vineyards. Paraje Calificado also requires vines at least 10 years old, hand harvesting and a single vintage.15,16,17

Prosecco Superiore is meant to be drunk young. Its consortium suggests enjoying it in the year after the harvest, as its fruity and floral aromas turn more mature with time.18

Sweetness labels, from Brut Nature to Doux

EU rules set the sweetness terms for sparkling wine by sugar per liter: Brut Nature under 3 g, Extra Brut 0–6 g, Brut under 12 g, Extra Dry 12–17 g, Dry (Sec) 17–32 g, Demi-Sec 32–50 g and Doux over 50 g.19

The names can mislead: under these ranges, Extra Dry contains more sugar than Brut. Brut Nature may be used only if no sugar was added after the second fermentation.19

Spanish labels use local words for the same steps: Extra Seco, Seco, Semi Seco and Dulce, alongside Brut Nature, Extra Brut and Brut.15

In Champagne, sweetness comes from the dosage, cane sugar dissolved in wine and added just before corking. For a Brut, the Comité says this is about 1 cl per 75 cl bottle.20

Prosecco DOC Spumante runs from Brut Nature to Demi-sec. The Prosecco Superiore consortium calls Dry the least common style and suggests serving it very cold to balance its sweetness.11,12

Price, food and serving

Wine Folly puts a good entry-level Champagne at about $40 and a good entry-level Prosecco under $20. It ties the gap to the costly traditional method versus the cheaper tank method, and to each wine's reputation.10

Wine Folly's holiday price tiers put Cava and Crémant under $20 and good Champagne at about $60.21

Wine Folly suggests Champagne with shellfish, fried appetizers and even potato chips, and Prosecco with cured meats, fruit-based appetizers and dishes like Pad Thai.10

The Prosecco Superiore consortium pairs Brut with fish and seafood pasta, Extra Dry with aperitifs and white meats such as poultry, and the bottle-fermented sui lieviti style with cured meats, cheese and pizza.12

The Comité Champagne suggests serving at about 8–10°C: 20–30 minutes in an ice bucket half filled with water and ice, or a few hours at the bottom of the fridge. It prefers a tulip-shaped glass, noting that flutes and coupes don't show the wine's full character.22

To open a bottle, the Comité advises gripping the cork firmly, never pointing the bottle at anyone, and turning the bottle rather than the cork so it comes out gently. Pour slowly until the glass is two-thirds full.22

Prosecco Superiore is best at 6–8°C in a fairly large tulip glass. Cava Reserva is suggested at 8–10°C and Paraje Calificado at 10–12°C, also in a tulip glass.15,17,18

Genuine Prosecco DOC is sold only in glass bottles and carries a state seal on the collar with a serial number. The consortium says to be suspicious of "Prosecco" sold on tap or in a can.3

Giving a bottle this season? Our wine gifts guide includes a sparkling wine that Wine Enthusiast scored 100 points, and the glassware guide covers the glass to serve it in.

Questions people ask

Is Prosecco just cheaper Champagne?

No. Prosecco comes from northeast Italy, is based on the Glera grape and usually gets its bubbles in large tanks. Champagne comes from a defined area of France, uses mainly Pinot Noir, Chardonnay and Meunier, and has its second fermentation in the bottle.

Is Cava made the same way as Champagne?

Yes. Cava uses the traditional method, with a second fermentation in the bottle, but with Spanish grapes such as Macabeo, Xarel·lo and Parellada. Its minimum time on the lees is nine months, against 15 for Champagne.

Which is drier, Brut or Extra Dry?

Brut. Under EU rules Brut has under 12 g of sugar per liter, while Extra Dry has 12–17 g. For the driest wines, look for Brut Nature (under 3 g) or Extra Brut (0–6 g).

Why does Champagne cost more than Prosecco or Cava?

Wine Folly points to the costly, slow traditional method and Champagne's luxury reputation. Champagne must also age at least 15 months on its lees before release. Wine Folly's tiers put Cava and most entry-level Prosecco under $20.

How cold should sparkling wine be?

The Comité Champagne suggests 8–10°C, chilled but not ice-cold. The Prosecco Superiore consortium suggests 6–8°C. Both prefer a tulip-shaped glass to a flute or coupe.

Sources

  1. "Champagne designation", Comité Champagne
  2. "Prosecco DOC", Consorzio di Tutela della DOC Prosecco
  3. "Recognizing Prosecco DOC", Consorzio di Tutela della DOC Prosecco
  4. "Conegliano Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG: The Wine", Consorzio di Tutela del Vino Conegliano Valdobbiadene Prosecco
  5. "The 4 zones of Cava", D.O. Cava Regulatory Board
  6. "Bottling and second fermentation", Comité Champagne
  7. "Maturation", Comité Champagne
  8. "Traditional Method", D.O. Cava Regulatory Board
  9. "Winemaking", Consorzio di Tutela della DOC Prosecco
  10. Madeline Puckette, "Champagne vs. Prosecco", Wine Folly (2015)
  11. "Types", Consorzio di Tutela della DOC Prosecco
  12. "Wine and food matching", Consorzio di Tutela del Vino Conegliano Valdobbiadene Prosecco
  13. "Champagne and its grape varieties", Comité Champagne
  14. "Authorised grape varieties", D.O. Cava Regulatory Board
  15. "Cava Reserva", D.O. Cava Regulatory Board
  16. "Cava Gran Reserva", D.O. Cava Regulatory Board
  17. "Cava de Paraje Calificado", D.O. Cava Regulatory Board
  18. "Storage and service", Consorzio di Tutela del Vino Conegliano Valdobbiadene Prosecco
  19. European Commission, "Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/33 (Annex III: sugar content of sparkling wines)", EUR-Lex, European Union (2018)
  20. "Dosage", Comité Champagne
  21. Madeline Puckette, "What Are You Drinking? Holiday Wine Guide", Wine Folly (2013)
  22. "Preparations for drinking Champagne", Comité Champagne