What natural wine means

Natural wine has no fixed definition. Decanter writer Christina Rasmussen says the term lacks a specific definition, and VinePair's Keith Beavers puts it bluntly: "There is no definition for it."1,2

In the EU, the word "natural" has no legal regulation for foods, according to a 2022 policy paper in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems.3

Writers broadly agree on the basics: grapes farmed organically or biodynamically, minimal intervention in the cellar and no additives. Most also expect the wine to be unfined and unfiltered, usually with spontaneous (wild-yeast) fermentation.1,4

The main point of disagreement is sulfur dioxide, which helps prevent oxidation. Rasmussen notes that some natural wine advocates say none should be added, some allow up to 30 ppm, and others allow under 70 ppm.1

A related label, "minimal intervention," is just as loose. It has no global regulation and means different things to different winemakers, and Decanter's report acknowledges that all winemaking is, by definition, intervention.5

Most wines sold today are clear. Pét-nat, a lightly sparkling style tied to the rise of natural wine, is usually unfined, unfiltered and often not disgorged, so many bottles show some haze and fine sediment.6

Orange wine is not the same thing. VinePair's Beavers advises against thinking of orange wine as natural wine, noting that orange wine has no rules and can be made in many ways.2

Where the movement came from

Rasmussen traces early mentions of natural wine to the 1800s, when the focus was on avoiding added sugar. By the 1980s, winemakers were turning to organic farming.1

In Beaujolais, chemist and winemaker Jules Chauvet influenced Marcel Lapierre, who took over his family domaine in 1973. Jean Foillard says Lapierre made his first natural cuvée in 1978.1,7

By 1980, Lapierre had joined Guy Breton, Jean-Paul Thévenet and Jean Foillard, a group importer Kermit Lynch named the Gang of Four. They dropped synthetic herbicides and pesticides, sorted grapes strictly, added little or no sulfur dioxide and did not add sugar.7

France's Vin Méthode Nature label

In March 2020, France launched a formal charter for natural wine under the name "vin méthode nature." Decanter reported that INAO, the Ministry of Agriculture and the fraud control office all recognized it, with a three-year trial period.3,8

The charter came from a natural wine union formed in 2019 by producers, merchants and consumers. Its rules require certified organic grapes, hand harvesting and only native yeasts, and allow no winemaking additives apart from a limited dose of sulfites.8,9,10

Banned techniques include thermovinification, cryo-extraction, reverse osmosis, filtration, flash pasteurization and centrifugation.8,10

No sulfites may be added before or during fermentation. One logo marks wines with no added sulfites; a second marks wines with a small addition and no more than 30 mg/L of total sulfites.8,10

The label is narrow. The union's own site says natural wine as such has no official recognition; only the term "vin méthode nature," on wines that earn the union's label, is officially recognized.9,10

Not everyone welcomed it. The Frontiers paper reports that the EU wine industry body CEEV questioned the label and the European Commission said it would seek clarification from France.3

Natural vs organic vs biodynamic

Organic and biodynamic are certified farming systems. Natural wine starts from that kind of farming and adds limits in the cellar, and the Frontiers paper notes that consumers often confuse the three.3

EU organic wine must be made from organic grapes and yeast, and must contain fewer sulfites than conventional wine. Sorbic acid and removing sulfur dioxide by physical means are banned.11

The EU's organic winemaking rules have applied since 1 August 2012. They cap sulfur dioxide at 100 mg/L for dry reds and 150 mg/L for dry whites and rosés, and ban practices such as partial dealcoholization and electrodialysis.12

In the United States, wine labeled "organic" may have no added sulfites. Wine "made with organic grapes" may contain up to 100 ppm of sulfites from sulfur dioxide and must disclose them.13

Demeter, the biodynamic certifier, calls biodynamics the world's oldest system of organic growing and describes the farm as a self-sustaining organism. It dates the movement to 1924.14

Under Demeter USA's rules, Biodynamic wine uses 100% biodynamic grapes from one estate and vintage, allows no added yeast, acid or sugar adjustments or enzymes, and caps sulfites at 100 ppm.15

Some natural wine groups set their own stricter rules. Italy's VinNatur, founded in 2006 and now about 300 producers in 12 countries, limits sulfites to 50 mg/L for whites and 30 mg/L for reds and has members' wines lab-tested for pesticide residues.4,16

The debate

Critics point to winemaking faults. Decanter's Richard Baudains notes the risk of excess volatile acidity, Brettanomyces and oxidation, and says some journalists have in the past branded natural wine undrinkable.4

Producers respond in different ways. Some defend unusual aromas as a sign of naturalness, others ask drinkers to adjust their expectations, and a third camp insists natural wines should be clean. Baudains argues they should be judged by the same standards as any wine.4

Certification is contested too. The Frontiers paper describes greenwashing by producers selling imitation natural wines, a French consumer-group scandal over pesticide residues in wines marketed as natural, and natural winemakers who oppose certification as bureaucratic.3

Virginia winemaker Maya Hood White says some producers talk up low-intervention winemaking while buying grapes from heavily farmed vineyards, and urges buyers to ask questions about farming.5

How to find it

Some wine shops and bars now focus only on natural wine, and natural wines increasingly appear on Michelin-starred wine lists.6

Natural wine groups hold tastings and fairs, such as VinNatur's annual show in Gambellara in Italy's Veneto and its New York event.4,16

Because the term is loose, Rasmussen advises not taking a "natural" claim for granted; her first question is whether the grapes come from a healthy, well-farmed environment. On French bottles, the Vin Méthode Nature logos show both certification and whether sulfites were added.1,8,10

Questions people ask

Is there a legal definition of natural wine?

Not in most places. The EU does not regulate the word "natural" for foods. France recognized a voluntary "vin méthode nature" label in 2020, but it covers only wines certified by its union, not natural wine in general.

Is natural wine the same as organic wine?

No. Organic is a certified standard. Natural wine usually starts with organic or biodynamic grapes, then avoids additives and most cellar techniques. Advocates accept none to 70 ppm of sulfites; EU organic rules allow 100–150 mg/L in dry wines.

Does natural wine contain sulfites?

Often a little. Advocates disagree: some add none, others allow up to 30 or 70 ppm. France's Vin Méthode Nature label allows no added sulfites, or a small addition up to 30 mg/L total, with a different logo for each.

Why is some natural wine cloudy?

Many natural wines are not fined or filtered. Pét-nats in particular are often left undisgorged, so they can show haze and fine sediment.

Is orange wine natural wine?

Not necessarily. Orange wine has no rules of its own and can be made in many ways. VinePair's Keith Beavers advises against thinking of orange wine as natural wine.

Sources

  1. Christina Rasmussen, "Natural wine: A lens on the future of wine and winemaking", Decanter (2024)
  2. VinePair Staff (host Keith Beavers), "Wine 101: Orange Wine", VinePair (2021)
  3. Pablo Alonso González, Eva Parga Dans, Rosana Fuentes Fernández, "Certification of Natural Wine: Policy Controversies and Future Prospects", Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems (2022)
  4. Richard Baudains, "Baudains: 'Natural wines don't stink'", Decanter (2024)
  5. Jillian Dara, "What does minimal intervention really mean?", Decanter (2024)
  6. Natalie Earl, "Pét-nat for beginners", Decanter (2023)
  7. The Editors, "The Origins of Natural Wine: A Conversation with Camille Lapierre and Jean Foillard", Grape Collective (2018)
  8. Chris Wilson, "Natural wine receives formal recognition in France under the name 'Vin Méthode Nature'", Decanter (2020)
  9. "Qui sommes-nous ?", Syndicat de Défense des Vins Méthode Nature
  10. "Le label (Notre charte)", Syndicat de Défense des Vins Méthode Nature
  11. "Organic production and products", European Commission, Agriculture and Rural Development
  12. European Commission, "Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 203/2012 (detailed rules on organic wine)", EUR-Lex, European Union (2012)
  13. "Alcohol FAQs: Labeling (organic claims)", Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB)
  14. "Demeter International", Demeter International
  15. "Wine: Understanding the Differences", Demeter USA
  16. "VinNatur: Association of Natural Winemakers", VinNatur